Paulo Silva Silva Lawyer
PT EN

Refusals, demolition orders, stop-work orders and declarations that a permit has lapsed are administrative acts. They can be challenged before the administrative courts, within short time limits and through the procedural route suited to each case.

When the procedure becomes a dispute

While the case is pending before the municipality — requests for further documents, prior hearing, administrative complaint — the defence is made within the procedure itself (Urban planning and licensing). Once an adverse decision has been taken, the route becomes judicial. It is the same matter, in two stages, handled by the same lawyer.

What I handle

  • Refusals — of licensing, prior notification, prior information requests and legalisation; claims for annulment and for an order requiring the municipality to issue the act that is due.
  • Demolition and reinstatement orders — challenge, suspension of enforcement and legalisation as an alternative.
  • Stop-work orders (embargo).
  • Lapse of permits and prior notifications.
  • Municipal plans and the Municipal Master Plan (PDM) — challenges to rules that affect how a property can be used or developed.
  • Expropriation and administrative easements.
  • Municipal liability — compensation for unlawful planning action.
  • Public procurement — challenges to exclusions and awards; pre-contractual litigation.
  • Environmental matters in real estate projects.
  • Property taxes — challenges to assessments of IMT, stamp duty, IMI, AIMI and real estate capital gains.

Time limits: the first thing to check

  • Voidable acts: three months, counted from notification to the interested party or to their representative (Article 58(1)(b) and Article 59(2) of the Code of Procedure in the Administrative Courts — CPTA).
  • Continuous counting under Article 279 of the Civil Code; if the time limit ends during court holidays or on a day the courts are closed, it moves to the next working day (Article 58(2) CPTA).
  • Null acts: may be challenged at any time (Article 58(1) CPTA). Distinguishing nullity from voidability is therefore decisive.
  • Interim relief and pre-contractual litigation are urgent proceedings and run during court holidays (Article 36 CPTA).
  • Tax challenges follow their own, different time limits.

Suspending enforcement while the case is pending

The main action takes time. Interim relief by way of suspension of effects protects the applicant in the meantime: once served, the public body may not begin or continue enforcing the act unless it recognises, in a reasoned resolution, that deferring enforcement would be seriously prejudicial to the public interest (Article 128(1) CPTA).

What you receive

  • A reading of the act and of its notification, with the date from which the time limit runs.
  • A map of time limits, with the applicable rule and the counting method.
  • An assessment of the defects and of the procedural route: challenge, order to issue the act that is due, interim relief.
  • A fee proposal by stage of the proceedings.

Frequently asked questions

Does a complaint to the municipality suspend the time limit for going to court?

It depends on the type of administrative challenge and on the applicable statute. Before filing a complaint, its effect on the judicial time limit is confirmed.

I am a neighbour of a licensed building project. Can I challenge the permit?

A third party with a direct interest may challenge it. For those who were not notified, the time limit runs from different events, set out in Article 59(3) CPTA.

The municipality did not decide within the legal time limit. What happens?

For acts governed by the Legal Framework for Urbanisation and Building (RJUE), once the time limit has passed without a decision, the application is deemed tacitly approved (Article 111(c) RJUE). See tacit approval under the new RJUE.

Which court decides?

The administrative and tax court with territorial jurisdiction, identified in the first analysis of the case.

Related reading

Areas covered

Support before the municipalities of Greater Lisbon — with particular proximity to Cascais, Oeiras, Sintra and the South Bank (Margem Sul) — and, by video conference, throughout the country.

Information and contact

Office at Lagoas Park, Building 7, in Oeiras. Meetings in person or by video conference, in Portuguese, English and Spanish.

Notice: before sharing documents, deadlines or the identity of the counterparty, please await confirmation that there is no conflict of interest and acceptance of the engagement. The information on this page is general in nature and does not constitute legal advice.

Information and contact

PT·EN
Book a callWhatsApp